Pre-order gift until March 8: a signed bookplate, a Kettle Bay map print and a bonus story. See the details

On sale March 9, 2027

Reading guide

Sixteen questions for book clubs and classrooms. Each one is tied to the page it comes from, so you can read the passage aloud before you talk. Spoilers start in Part Three.

Part One · Ice-In

1

The book opens with a rule: a lantern on the dock until the last one is in. Who is the rule really for, the people on the ice or the people waiting?

2

Chapter 1 · p. 3

Signe adds her father’s date to the ledger herself. What does it mean that nobody else does?

3

Chapter 1 · p. 4

Walt Pederson knows the ice better than anyone, and says almost nothing. How does the book use silence?

4

Chapter 3 · p. 41

Chapter Four is named for a measurement. What other numbers carry feeling in this book?

Chapter 4 · p. 57

Part Two · Deep Cold

5

Marit wants to sell and Henrik wants to stay. Whose side were you on by the end of Part Two, and did it change?

6

Chapter 6 · p. 104

What does the ledger know that the people do not? Why does Signe trust it more than her mother?

7

Chapter 6 · p. 112

How is Dale Kittleson, the buyer from Brainerd, different from what Signe expects?

8

Chapter 8 · p. 149

The search line is the most crowded scene in the book. What does the community do well, and what does it get wrong?

Chapter 5 · p. 88

Part Three · Rotten Ice

9

“Candled” ice looks solid and is not. Where else in the novel does something look solid and is not?

10

Chapter 9 · p. 175

Everybody on the lake had a reason to keep the light going. List them. Which one surprised you?

11

Chapter 10 · p. 214

Was Marit right to sell? Was she right to keep the secret?

12

Chapter 11 · p. 247

How did you feel about Arne by the end of Part Three?

Chapter 11 · p. 255

Part Four · Ice-Out

13

Thirty-two years later, Signe comes back. What has she carried, and what has she put down?

14

Chapter 12 · p. 259

Why does the lantern end up in a shed and not a museum, a lake or a trash can?

15

Chapter 12 · p. 271

The last chapter is called “The Last Light.” Did the ending feel earned?

16

Chapter 14 · p. 331

What would you have written in the ledger on the last page?

Chapter 14 · p. 358

Take it with you

The same guide as a two-page PDF, with the map on the back.

For teachers

Annika taught ninth grade for eleven years. A classroom version with vocabulary, a setting map and two writing prompts is free for schools: ask for it here.

“A rule that old must work.”

Chapter 1 · p. 4